After a slip and fall in Arizona, collect evidence as soon as you safely can. Photos of the hazard and surrounding area, witness information, medical records, incident reports, surveillance footage, and documentation of your losses can help establish what happened and support a premises-liability claim. Because conditions can change quickly, early documentation can be especially important.
A fall on another person’s property does not automatically establish negligence. Arizona case law generally requires a plaintiff in a business-premises slip-and-fall case to show that the dangerous condition resulted from the defendant’s acts, that the defendant had actual knowledge of the condition, or that the condition existed long enough that the defendant should have discovered it through reasonable care. Arizona courts have also recognized a mode-of-operation theory in certain circumstances involving recurring transitory hazards.
That makes evidence about the condition itself, how long it may have existed, who knew about it, what inspections or maintenance occurred, and how the accident happened particularly important.
Preuss v. Sambo’s of Arizona, Inc.
Chiara v. Fry’s Food Stores of Arizona, Inc.
Arizona’s comparative-negligence statute provides that when a claimant is found partly at fault, the claimant’s damages are reduced in proportion to the claimant’s relative degree of fault. The statute does not create a general rule that a person who is 50% or more at fault automatically recovers nothing. The original draft made that incorrect claim.
Evidence should address the complete circumstances of the fall, including where you were walking, what you could see, lighting, warning signs, footwear, the location and nature of the hazard, and what the property owner or occupier did or failed to do.
Arizona Revised Statutes § 12-2505
Move to a safe location if necessary and seek emergency medical assistance when appropriate. Do not put yourself at additional risk simply to photograph or collect evidence.
Notify the property owner, manager, employee, security personnel, landlord, or other responsible person as soon as reasonably possible. Ask whether an incident report is being prepared and keep a copy if one is provided. If no report is provided, write down who you notified, what you reported, and the date and time.
Take photographs before the condition changes whenever it is safe to do so. Use both wide shots and close-ups. Photograph the exact place of the fall, the hazard, surrounding area, lighting, warning signs, your injuries, and damaged clothing or footwear. Preserve original files.
Ask witnesses for names and reliable contact information. A witness may have seen the fall, noticed the hazard beforehand, or observed what happened immediately afterward. Record what people voluntarily tell you without coaching them.
Keep damaged clothing and footwear in their post-accident condition when practical. Do not wash, repair, discard, or alter items that may be relevant before discussing preservation. Do not enter a dangerous area or remove property you are not entitled to take.
Medical documentation can help connect the injury to the accident and document the nature and extent of treatment. Seek appropriate medical attention, particularly when symptoms are significant, worsening, or potentially urgent.
Be accurate and consistent when describing the accident and symptoms. If treatment was delayed, tell your provider when symptoms began and why you waited.
In a traditional Arizona business-premises slip-and-fall case, evidence may be relevant to whether the defendant created the condition, actually knew about it, or should have discovered it through reasonable care. Evidence can include:
Surveillance footage can show the condition, surrounding area, fall itself, employee activity, and what happened before or after the incident. Private businesses may routinely overwrite footage, and there is no universal rule requiring every recording to be kept for a fixed number of days.
If surveillance may exist, identify the cameras and request that potentially relevant footage be preserved promptly. An attorney can send a preservation letter and, when appropriate, pursue discovery or other legal procedures to obtain relevant recordings. Do not state that a business automatically commits a legal violation merely because footage was overwritten; preservation duties and remedies depend on the circumstances.
An incident report may identify the time and location of the accident, employees who responded, the reported condition, witnesses, photographs, or other observations. Internal maintenance and inspection records may help establish what inspections occurred and whether a recurring problem had been reported. A business may not voluntarily provide every internal record, so relevant documents may need to be sought through appropriate discovery.
If the injury affected your ability to work, preserve documentation showing the financial impact.
Medical restrictions can also help document why you could not perform certain duties or needed time away from work.
Yes. If the fall occurred outdoors, document rain, standing water, ice, snow, poor lighting, drainage problems, debris, or other environmental factors. Historical weather information can provide additional context when weather is relevant.
Identify the business, property owner, landlord, manager, or other potentially responsible parties if you can do so safely. The business operating at a location may not be the same entity that owns the property. Ownership, leasing, maintenance, and control arrangements can affect which parties may have duties concerning a property.
If you have visible injuries, dated photographs can document how bruising, swelling, wounds, or scars change over time. Keep original files and retain the dates and context. Photographs are evidence; they do not by themselves establish the full value or legal cause of an injury.
After an accident, an insurer or property representative may contact you. Be truthful, but avoid guessing about facts you do not know. Before giving a recorded statement, signing a release, or accepting a settlement, consider obtaining legal advice so you understand what you are being asked to provide or give up. Do not make false statements or conceal relevant facts.
Tell your attorney promptly if relevant evidence has disappeared, been overwritten, or been destroyed. Whether a court can impose a remedy depends on circumstances including what the evidence was, whether it was relevant, when a duty to preserve arose, and what prejudice resulted. Do not assume that missing video automatically entitles you to an adverse inference or monetary sanction.
An attorney can help identify evidence that may not be obvious at the scene and use appropriate legal procedures to obtain relevant information. Depending on the case, this may include:
The most useful evidence is often evidence that preserves what the scene looked like, documents your injuries and treatment, identifies witnesses, and helps establish how the dangerous condition came to exist. Start with what you can safely document yourself, preserve the originals, and seek legal guidance when the case involves disputed liability, significant injuries, surveillance footage, or evidence that may be difficult to obtain.
If you were injured in a slip and fall, an attorney can review the circumstances of the accident and help identify evidence needed to evaluate a premises-liability claim. That may include the condition of the property, notice of the hazard, medical documentation, witnesses, surveillance, and the financial impact of the injury.
Big Chad Law represents clients in Arizona personal injury matters and can review your circumstances, explain potential options, and help determine what evidence should be preserved.
Learn about Big Chad Law’s Arizona legal services
You can still document the scene as soon as possible. Conditions may have changed, but later photographs, witness information, incident records, medical documentation, and other evidence may still help establish what happened.
Arizona’s interception laws contain specific rules concerning consent and recording. Do not assume that every conversation can safely be recorded simply because you are participating in it. Consider obtaining legal advice before recording a conversation for use in a claim.
There is no universal private-business rule requiring every surveillance recording to be retained for a fixed number of days. Systems may overwrite footage as part of routine operation. If a claim may involve video, request preservation promptly.
Arizona generally reduces damages in proportion to a claimant’s relative fault. Partial fault does not automatically bar recovery under A.R.S. § 12-2505, although the amount recoverable can be affected by the assigned percentage of fault.
You can document many things yourself, especially photographs, witness information, medical records, and expenses. An attorney can also help identify evidence held by other parties and use appropriate legal procedures to obtain records or footage.
Keep your own record of when and to whom you reported the incident. Witness information, emails, texts, photographs, medical records, and other contemporaneous documentation may help establish that the report was made.
Delayed treatment does not automatically eliminate a claim, but the reason for the delay and the connection between the accident and the injury can become issues. Seek appropriate medical care and accurately explain when symptoms began.
Document whatever evidence remains, including photographs, witness accounts, incident records, messages, and other records. A changed condition does not by itself establish liability, so the available evidence should be evaluated as a whole.
This article provides general legal information and is not legal advice. Arizona premises-liability and personal-injury claims depend on the facts of the individual case, including the property involved, the nature of the hazard, notice, causation, damages, comparative fault, and applicable deadlines. Consult a qualified Arizona attorney for advice about your specific circumstances.
Disclaimer: This article is provided by Big Chad Law for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this content does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, fees, regulations, and court decisions referenced may change. For advice on your specific situation, please contact Big Chad Law directly to schedule a consultation.